Retread vs. New Truck Tires: Compare Fitment and Cost per Kilometre

Published · Updated
Compare new tires and a retread proposal for the same axle, vehicle, route and load. This guide gives you a worksheet for actual quotes and service records; it does not assume that either option always lasts longer, uses less fuel or is safer. Pneus Québec’s linked catalogue presents new tires. A retread quote and casing assessment must come from a provider offering that service.
Cost-per-kilometre worksheet: use your own figures
Use the same number of tires and the same service period in both columns. Enter CAD consistently before or after recoverable taxes. Leave unknowns blank and mark forecasts as estimates. Do not divide by zero or compare a measured distance with an unlabelled forecast.
| Input for one tire or a comparable set | Retread option (CAD) | New-tire option (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| A — Purchase or retread charge | Your quote | Your quote |
| B — Casing acquisition, inspection and repairs, if charged separately | Your quote | Your quote |
| C — Freight, mounting and attributable service/repair costs | Your records | Your records |
| D — Disposal and other attributable charges | Your records | Your records |
| E — Confirmed casing credit or residual value | Your records | Your records |
| K — Recorded service distance (km) | Your records | Your records |
| Total cost = A + B + C + D − E | Calculate | Calculate |
| Cost per km = total cost ÷ K | Calculate when K > 0 | Calculate when K > 0 |
Count each cost or credit once. For a casing already owned, choose and disclose a consistent basis: incremental cash cost for the next service life, or whole-casing lifecycle cost. Do not allocate the same original casing cost in every retread cycle. Treat downtime or fuel differences separately unless supported by comparable records.
Download the blank tire-cost worksheet (CSV)
Compare current 11R22.5 new-tire models
Request a new-tire quote for your application
Manufacturer reference: Michelin on casing inspection and retreading
Manufacturer reference: Michelin Truck Tire Service Manual, cost analysis
A retread reuses a casing that a retreader has inspected and accepted, then applies a replacement tread. A new tire starts with a new casing and tread. Retread eligibility depends on inspection and the relevant manufacturer and retreader requirements; an existing casing is not automatically suitable.
Compare the exact tire or tread model and its approved application. Size alone does not establish load capacity, axle suitability, rolling resistance or mileage. Ask for the service description and manufacturer documentation for the wheel and vehicle involved.
Use current written quotes. Any casing purchase, inspection, repair, rejection charge or credit must be made explicit. We do not assume a fixed percentage saving for retreads or a universal lifetime advantage for new tires.

Safety and maintenance depend on the exact product, accepted casing condition, correct fitment and ongoing inspection. Have the supplier confirm suitability for the vehicle and axle, including applicable requirements. This article does not certify a tire or authorize a change of fitment.
Retreading can extend the use of an accepted casing. To compare environmental or fuel performance, request evidence for the exact products and application. A tire dimension, a new-tire label or a retread label alone does not prove a fuel saving.
| Compare | Retread proposal | New-tire proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Fitment | Accepted casing, tread and approved application | Exact model and approved application |
| Upfront cost | Retreading plus any casing, inspection and repair costs | New tire purchase and preparation costs |
| Service record | Actual distance and removal reason for this application | Actual distance and removal reason for this application |
| End of service | Confirmed casing credit or disposal cost | Confirmed casing credit or disposal cost |
Questions to ask the retreading provider
A retread proposal can make use of a casing already in your fleet. Ask who owns the casing, how acceptance is assessed, which repairs are included, what happens if it is rejected, and which tread and warranty are quoted. Include these terms in the cost comparison.
Questions to ask the new-tire supplier
A new-tire proposal should identify the exact model, application, quantity, warranty and installed cost. If future retreading is part of your plan, ask the supplier and retreader about casing eligibility and ownership; do not assume a future credit or another service life.
Make separate comparisons for direction, traction and remorque applications. Record the same route, load, pressure-maintenance practices and removal criteria. Compare measured service lives where available; label untested mileage as an assumption.
Pneus Québec can quote the new tires shown in its current catalogue. Send the dimension, application, quantity and requested reception method. Available stock, price, taxes, delivery and installation are confirmed with the quote. Contact (438) 817-4112 or [email protected].
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a retread always cost less per kilometre?
No. Compare the full attributable cost and recorded distance for comparable applications. A lower purchase price alone does not establish a lower operating cost.
Which option uses less fuel?
Request evidence for the exact new tire or retread tread design in comparable service. Do not assign a fuel saving solely because a tire is new or retreaded.
Does Pneus Québec offer retreading?
This guide compares purchasing decisions. The linked Pneus Québec catalogue offers new tires; ask a retreading provider for casing inspection and a retread proposal.
Record the result for your fleet
Choose using documented suitability and comparable total costs. Keep the quote, service records, distance at installation and removal, and any casing credit together. Review the outcome after the tires have completed a comparable service period.
Best Waste Management Truck Tires for Fleets: Cut Costs & Improve Efficiency
Top Fuel Efficient Truck Tires For Fleets: Cut Fuel Costs & Save More